Saturday, March 14, 2009

Posing the Hypothetical

Hypothetical Players: Favorite pair of shoes. Animal. Owner of shoes. Owner of animal. 

Hypothetical Scenario: animal chews up favorite pair of shoes owned by person who does not own the animal. 

Hypothetical Question: Does animal owner now owe the non-animal owner a new pair of shoes? 

Hypothetical Answer: Non-animal owner thinks "yes," animal owner thinks "no."

Hypothetical Curiosity: What do third parties (read: you) think?

2 comments:

  1. If my dog destroyed something that belonged to someone else, I'd feel obligated to replace it. Hands down. -- Brooke

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yup. I agree with Brooke. No question about it. --Becky

    ReplyDelete